The Cool Wall has been created at the Manga Cafe. Decisions were made by voting, there were some arguments! But this is what we came up with in the end, even if some people aren't happy with where some ended up. We did have a few rules:

1. Sub-Zero - If even one person voted something as Uncool, or disagreed with something being allowed into Sub-Zero, then it couldn't go in.
2. Seriously Uncool - If even one person objects it can't be put into Seriously Uncool.
3. For Cool/Uncool placing - the majority rules.
4. Don't vote just on looks, you have to have at least tried to read it to vote.

You may be thinking, but I like that Manga that has been put in Uncool - many times so did the people placing it in Uncool, you may like it, it may be entertaining, but is it really cool?
The positioning within the Cool or Uncool areas is roughly based on how cool they were, how many votes. Where there was an equal split of votes between Cool and Uncool they have been placed on the borderline.